The Wholesale Suspension of Disbelief:
"Even in the best of times an armed officer's work is inherently dangerous and stressful in ways that people in other occupations and professions may not be able to imagine."
Police officers investigate the scene of an early afternoon shooting in Old Town Arvada on June 21, 2021
Once again events seem to be attempting to force a reckoning regarding policing and gun violence in America, while the role of socially destabilizing violent entertainment fare never features prominently in what passes for a public discussion.
Officer Gordon Beesley had been with the Arvada Police Department for 19 years when he was ambushed and killed by a heavily armed lunatic on Monday, June 21. The gunman, who had expressed hatred of police officers and who had an as yet undisclosed political agenda, was then shot and killed by a heroic citizen, John Hurley, of Golden, CO, who was armed with a pistol. The Arvada Police Department reports that Hurley was then shot and killed by a police officer as he stood holding the assault rifle he had taken from the gunman.
On Saturday, April 10, Iowa State Patrol sergeant Jim Smith, 51, was shot and killed as he and other officers were attempting to apprehend a deranged man with a lengthy criminal record and substance abuse issues, a man who should never have been allowed access to a firearm. Smith, a 27-year veteran officer, was remembered by Governor Kim Reynolds as "a loving husband, father of two, and a pillar of the community." Sergeant Smith's death came on the heels of the March 22 supermarket mass shooting in Boulder, Colorado, in which BPD officer Eric Talley, 51, and nine others were killed by a mentally unstable young man who, again, should never have been allowed access to a firearm. Talley, an 11-year veteran, left behind a wife and seven children. On April 16 from Indianapolis came news of yet another tragic mass shooting. Yet another mentally unstable young man with legally-purchased semi-
In the midst of the trial of former Minneapolis Police Department officer Derek Chauvin for the death of George Floyd, watershed events that have had the eyes-on attention of a great many and perhaps most Americans, came the deadly shooting of yet another Black man, Daunte Wright, by a police officer in a Minneapolis suburb on Sunday, April 11. Brooklyn Center Police Department officer Kimberly Potter shot Wright during a traffic stop. Potter, a 26-year veteran of the BCPD, submitted her resignation. She has been charged with manslaughter in what BCPD Chief Tim Gannon described as an accidental shooting. Body-cam video seems to support Potter's assertion that the shooting was an accident in that her intention was to fire her Taser. Chief Gannon also resigned.
What is going on in America? For too many of us, living in this country is like living in a state of war, declares a recent headline in The Boston Globe. How are Americans to understand this apparently endless series of tragedies, a perpetual real life horror show? Two different issues, "officer involved shootings" and gun violence more generally, cannot be considered separately. The latter is essential context for understanding the former, as the recent tragedy in Arvada, CO, so clearly illustrates.
As paramilitary organizations whose officers are authorized to use deadly force under certain circumstances, law enforcement agencies are a lot like other bureaucracies only more so. American law enforcement cultures tend to reflect the attitudes of a) their leadership, b) the political cultures of the city, county, state, and nation, and c) the tenor and temper of the prevailing popular culture, not necessarily in that order. Even in the best of times an armed law enfiorcement officer's work is inherently dangerous and stressful in ways that people in other occupations and professions may not be able to imagine.
It is utterly unsurprising that law enforcement agency cultures can tend to become insular, paranoid, and reactionary when the popular culture in which they exist and function becomes hideously violent, political rhetoric becomes crude and hateful, and political culture becomes extremely divisive, especially during an era when federally-funded gun violence research has been effectively prohibited for decades by lawmakers in thrall to the NRA and gun laws are so lax that any damn fool can get his hands on semi-automatic weapons designed to kill as quickly a shooter can pull the trigger, and many have. Gun violence is epidemic in the USA. The nation is awash in firearms, and 2020 saw a record number of more than 600 mass shooting incidents that accounted for only a tiny fraction of the 43,549 deaths by firearm last year. President Biden has referred to the situation as "a public health crisis ... an epidemic [and] a national embarrassment."
It should be equally unsurprising that cops, too, want to go home to their families at the end of the workday. Despite the phony blame game the gun lobby and Hollywood play so well, it is increasingly clear that lawmakers, the gun lobby, and entertainment industry executives have long conspired to make law enforcement, an inherently demanding, dangerous and stressful profession, increasingly and unnecessarily more difficult and more hazardous. Ours is a heavily mediated culture in which lucrative, socially destabilizing fictional depictions of gun violence that glamorize and glorify violent criminality, murder, mayhem, and torture are routinely and systematically presented as popular entertainment fare to mass sudiences on screens large and small. As a result, real law enforcement officers such as the late Gordon Beesley, officers with real badges and real uniforms become prominent targets along with other real Americans who are killed or wounded in increasingly frequent mass shootings in schools, workplaces, places of worship, shopping malls, supermarkets, movie theaters, and other public spaces across our country.
The entertainment industry's fictional world of policing and gun violence does not accurately reflect the actual reality of life in America. Hollywood entertainment product is not crafted to inform audiences but to capture public attention for both profit and narrow political advantage. Most modern fictional media product requires viewers to turn off their critical thinking ability, that is, to "suspend disbelief," in order to achieve catharsis. Television producers, motion picture producers and video game creators are in the business of "capturing eyeballs," that is, capturing the attention of mass audiences in order to sell those audiences to advertisers. In America, television producers depend on commercials aired during breaks in programming and on "product placement," products seen or mentioned during programming, for profit. The more eyeballs captured, the more money producers can demand for a program, which is crafted with a focus on profitability along with additional considerations including the social and political agendas of the media moguls who own and operate the media conglomerates that produce and distribute or purchase and distribute media programming. Movie and video game profits depend on ticket sales and game prices, as well as product sales and product placement fees.
Entertainment industry commentators are quick to declare any suggestion that Jews own or "control the media" is an anti-Semitic trope. Yet anyone who looks at the credits following major network television programs and motion pictures sees a preponderance of Jewish surnames. Jewish authors have explored, described, commented on, and confirmed outsized Jewish influence in media again and again in books and newspaper articles. An alarming increase of anti-Jewish sentiment followed the extraordinarily divisive Trump 2016 general election political campaign that featured racist far-Right rhetoric and white supremacist race baiting. After Trump's election, violence worsened with deadly incidents at a "Unite the Right" rally in Charlottesville, VA, August 2017, and in a mass shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, PA, in late October 2018, among others. Ironically, there is a strong argument to be made that had not highly questionable party politics and special interest group money and influence ultimately forced Americans to choose in 2016 between the two most widely distrusted and disliked candidates in modern American political history, voters might well have elected the progressive populist United States Senator from Vermont, Bernie Sanders, a Jew. (Full disclosure: I've caucused for Sanders twice.) Is it not also noteworthy that it was Les Moonves, then executive vice president and CEO of CBS, arguably the single most influential individual in broadcast media at the time, whose public support for the Trump gravy train legitimized Trump's candidacy and ensured that attention, incredibly valuable free publicity, and early money would flow to the former reality TV show "star"? Moonves, later disgraced and removed from his powerful position at CBS, was honored by the Hollywood elite at a 2018 gala where it was noted that he was a great nephew of David Ben-Gurion, a founder and the first president of Israel. Recalling the truly remarkable popularity of Senator Sanders grass roots campaign in 2016 and the huge crowds he consistently drew, is it unfair to ask, "How big a problem can anti-Semitism be when a Jewish candidate for president is revealed to be so widely and wildly popular that persistent machinations by a major party are necessary to prevent his nomination?" Is it unfair to ask who, exactly, is responsible for the increase in anti-Semitism in America since 2016, if not the Zionist political machine, which clearly preferred either Trump or Clinton over Sanders, a progressive Jew? Who profits directly from evidence of anti-Jewish sentiment in America if not the organizations that "fight anti-Semitism", which see their donations increase when hate crimes against Jews increase? Has not the wholesale manipulation of American politics and popular culture for private profit and political advantage become a very dangerous game? Might there not, after all, be a limit to American gullibility, a limit to Americans' willingness and ability to suspend disbelief?
No public official is above the law, but, frankly, blaming law enforcement officers for an increase in gun violence makes about as much sense as rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic, and doing so will be just that effective. The socially destabilizing effects of violent media product on people who view it regularly, and its role as a causeative factor in real world violence have been extensively studied and thoroughly documented by many hundreds of social scientists over several decades:
"Though the scientific debate over whether media violence increases aggression and violence is essentially over, several critical tasks remain. Additional laboratory and field studies are needed for a better understanding of underlying psychological processes, which eventually should lead to more effective interventions. Large-scale longitudinal studies would help specify the magnitude of media-violence effects on the most severe types of violence. Meeting the larger societal challenge of providing children and youth with a much healthier media diet may prove to be more difficult and costly, especially if the scientific, news, public policy, and entertainment communities fail to educate the general public about the real risks of media-violence exposure to children and youth." --Craig A. Anderson, Leonard Berkowitz, Edward Donnerstein, L. Rowell Huesmann, James D. Johnson, Daniel Linz, Neil M. Malamuth, and Ellen Wartella, 2003.
The entertainment industry has pumped out increasing amounts of increasingly violent, lucrative, socially-destabilizing entertainment product advertising, glamorizing and glorifying guns and gun violence for decades. The resulting damage, spanning at least three generations of American social, cultural, political, and spiritual life, is incalculable. It will take decades and generational change to repair that damage, if the base instincts, crimes, and excesses of industry moguls, their "stars", and the politicians who take their money are reined in.
Under the circumstances, it would seem painfully obvious that the entertainment industry ought to find a way to cease and desist systematically glamorizing and glorifying gun violence for profit and political advantage in media products that are so clearly socially destabilizing and harmful. Popular cultural attitudes about violence are shaped and informed by the deluge of hideously violent entertainment fare. Decades of peer-reviewed social science research provides overwhelmingly persuasive evidence. Public attitudes regarding violence, gun violence in particular, must change if our public and private spaces are to become reasonably safe and law enforcement officers are to be able to suit up and show up for work without the all-too-reasonable and too often debilitating fear that has become, in too many cases, unbearable, causing one tragic officer involved shooting after another. The great majority of American law enforcement professionals hold themselves to very high standards, but it is painfully evident that America is asking much too much of its law enforcement officers. Lawmakers, the gun lobby, and the entertainment industry have put law enforcement officers, people of color, our criminal justice system, and our entire society in an untenable position.
Hollywood's "stars" who glamorize and glorify gun violence and torture are typically millionaires who expose themselves to no appreciable personal risk or threat while prancing around in front of cameras firing blanks and talking tough. Many media moguls are billionaires. Some, like Arnon Milchan, reported to be worth $3.4 billion, have controversial and highly questionable political agendas. Others, like the creator and executive producer of NBC's The Blacklist, Jon Bokenkamp, are merely millionaires many times over. The Blacklist, whose producers, writers, and "stars" routinely glamorize and glorify Russian organized crime, guns, and gun violence also tend to be big on torture. An April episode featured a Black woman as both torturer and victim of torture, which apparently passes for equal opportunity employment in Hollywood. Make no mistake: there is no redeeming social value in glamorizing and glorifying torture as popular entertainment fare, especially so the torture of women. But then, some male judges still minimize sex crimes perpetrated against girls and women while giving men, especially very rich men, the benefit of the doubt or whatever other benefit seems to suit them, so perhaps the entertainment industry's routine portrayal of the torture of women as entertainment fare for mass audiences should be unsurprising even if some Americans still find it shocking. James Spader, the "star" of The Blacklist, reportedly makes $300,000 per prime time episode or $6.6 million per season. Spader is reported to be NBC's highest paid "star." (In a cynical era when honorable public officials are widely perceived to be anomalies and cultural curiosities, this reporter is reasonably certain that no entertainment industry mover and shaker has any interest whatsoever in accurately depicting real law enforcement administrators such as Polk County Florida Sheriff Grady Judd.)
Unlike Hollywood's "stars" who glamorize and glorify guns and gun violence for fame and profit, real law enforcement officers work for a living and risk their lives every day. Few cops are millionaires. The base pay for Arvada Police Officer recruits was $61,808.28 in 2020. Iowa State Patrol sergeant Jim Smith's base salary at 27 years of service was less than $100,000 per year. The full salary range for Boulder Police officers is $67,378.27 to $96,006.35 per year. A nonprofit group that supports first responders announced that it would pay off slain BPD officer Eric Talley's mortgage. Many of the "stars" who glamorize and glorify socially destabilizing gun violence for mass audiences make more money per single fictional prime time police procedural episode than a typical law enforcement officer earns in one year, two years, three years or more. Exactly what kind of heaven is it where multimillionaire "stars" gin up epidemic levels of gun violence and mass murder in which real law enforcement heroes are gunned down in a hail of bullets and bleed out on the street or the floor alongside ordinary Americans guilty only of chancing to be in the wrong place at the wrong time while working, shopping, worshiping, or sitting in a classroom or a movie theater?
Among those real Americans whose perspectives, voices, and activities are routinely excluded, misrepresented, or mocked by the entertainment industry and its and affiliated news outlets are progressive Christians. These are Christians who are not impressed by exclusivist theologies or racist militancy. Perhaps it is because progressive Christians so seldom commit mass murder that major media corporations, imbued with a hugely lucrative and hideously violent entertainment product ethos, find them and their activities uninteresting and unworthy of readers and viewers' attention. Or, perhaps it is because progressive Christians sometimes speak out publicly and engage in nonviolent activism in behalf of peace, social justice, and good government, take a very dim view of torture, and harbor various other sentiments out of sync with an imperialist foreign policy. More than 20 years of reporting on Christian, Jewish, and Muslim activists who work together across the dividing lines of politics, race, and religion in America was often stressful and frustrating for this reporter. The work was stressful because of the frequent death threats I received. I found it interesting to learn that scholars who study and publish research about the role of violent and hyper-violent media product as a factor in real world violence also receive death threats. The work was frustrating in that major media news outlets routinely and more or less consistently ignore nonviolent activism in behalf of peace and social justice or report on such activities, if at all, so as to marginalize nonviolent activism rather than to inform their audiences. Major media entertainment programming, prime time fictional police procedurals and such, like major media news programming, routinely treats dissenting voices and nonviolent protest as if such First Amendment protected activities were vaguely disreputable at best if not quite as dangerous as violent terrorist activity. That is why most Americans have never heard of Mark Braverman, for instance.
Americans can expect little progress with regard to race relations, politics, social change, and a nonviolent way forward absent a much more substtantive and meaningful public discussion regarding race, religion, spirituality, and the role of violent media product as a causative factor in real world violence. Major media figures who are suddenly concerned about the future of American democracy following the January 6 insurrection at the Capitol would do well to reconsider their aversion to reporting on the efforts of progressive religionists, on interfaith peace and social justice activism, and on the role of violent media product in real world violence. Why? Because Americans, long immersed in a toxic media culture that systematically glamorizes and glorifies guns, socially-destabilizing gun violence and torture for profit and political advantage desperately need role models who enjoy working together across the dividing lines of politics, race, gender, religion, and class.
We can watch our country tear itself apart, or we can find new ways to resolve our differences peacefully and work together toward our many common goals so that our children and our grandchildren might have a bright future.





.jpg)






_1870-1876%20(1).jpg)